Last updated: 8 November 2026

By Stiv · Design, technology and personal finance

I book nearly all my UK train travel in the TrainPal app, and I have also tried buying tickets and an upgrade in Seatfrog. This comparison comes from my own bookings in October 2026 and from Seatfrog's own help centre.

Affiliate disclosure: This article contains affiliate and referral links, which are paid links. If you click one and buy or sign up, I earn a commission or referral bonus at no extra cost to you. Brands don't choose what I feature or what I say about them.

This is not financial advice. I write here as a TrainPal customer who has also tried Seatfrog, and both apps can change their fares, fees and offers at any time.

New to TrainPal?

My TrainPal referral page has the current welcome offer for new users and the steps to claim it.

See the TrainPal welcome offer

TrainPal vs SeatfrogTrain apps

How TrainPal and Seatfrog compare on fares, fees, Railcards and upgrades

TrainPal vs Seatfrog is less of a straight fight than it looks, because the two apps do different jobs. TrainPal is built around finding a lower fare, with automatic split tickets, Railcards and its own TrainPal Card discount. Seatfrog's main draw is cheaper First Class, through upgrade auctions on nine train companies, plus Train Swap for moving to a different train. I book almost everything in TrainPal. When I tried buying the same tickets in Seatfrog, every price came out higher for me.

More on TrainPal? My TrainPal guides hub collects my full review, how the membership tiers and PalPoints work, and how TrainPal compares with the other big booking apps.

TrainPal vs Seatfrog at a glance

Both apps sell UK train tickets, but TrainPal is built around the fare and Seatfrog around the upgrade. Here is how they line up on the things that change what you pay.

TrainPalSeatfrog
Main jobFinding a lower fare on UK and European trainsCheaper First Class upgrades, plus tickets and Train Swap
Booking fee on ticketsNone in the app on UK train tickets. Bookings on the TrainPal website can carry a feeNone on tickets, according to Seatfrog
Upgrade feeNo upgrade auctions£3 booking fee per ticket on every winning bid and every Upgrade Now purchase
RailcardsYes, on tickets, including split tickets. You can also buy a digital Railcard in the appYes on standard tickets. Not on upgrades, Train Swap, Secret Fare or Superfare
Split ticketsFound automatically when splitting is cheaperUpgrades work on split tickets that cover the whole journey
UpgradesUpgrade vouchers on the Gold tier and aboveAuctions and fixed-price Upgrade Now on nine train companies
Changing your trainChanges and refunds in the app, with fees on some ticketsTrain Swap, priced per train before you pay
LoyaltyPalPoints, PalWallet cashback and four membership tiersI struggled to find a points scheme
Refer a friendA welcome discount for new users£5 off a friend's first upgrade, and £5 off your next one

I checked both apps' fees, Railcard rules and Seatfrog's partner list on 8 November 2026.


App 01

What TrainPal is for

TrainPal is mainly a ticket app. It searches UK and European trains, then stacks every discount it can onto the fare. For me, that means my Railcard, a TrainPal Card and any PalWallet balance or promo code I have at the time.

At the end of October I booked two off-peak day returns to Windsor. My Two Together Railcard took £11.10 off the pair, and my TrainPal Card then took another £3.32 off on top. In total, that is £14.42 off two short day trips.

The TrainPal Card is the discount that Seatfrog can't match. It costs £25 for 90 days and takes 10% off UK train bookings, up to £10 off any one booking. It also doesn't renew automatically, so I buy a new one each time the last one runs out. My TrainPal review walks through a longer booking with every discount stacked.

Split tickets in TrainPal

In early October I went to Wales, and TrainPal split the journey into separate tickets without me asking. At first I found it confusing, because I assumed split tickets meant changing trains. In fact, I stayed on the same train the whole way.

That is how split tickets normally work. You hold two or more tickets for one journey, and the train has to stop at the station where one ticket ends and the next begins. TrainPal's split ticket guide sets out the rule: the train you board must stop at every place your tickets cover. Your Railcard still applies to each ticket, too.


App 02

What Seatfrog is for

Seatfrog does sell train tickets, to more than 3,400 destinations, and it says it charges no booking fees on them. However, its main feature is the upgrade. Seatfrog runs First Class upgrade auctions for nine train companies: Avanti West Coast, CrossCountry, East Midlands Railway, Grand Central, Greater Anglia, GWR, LNER, TransPennine Express and Transport for Wales. On Avanti West Coast, it also sells upgrades to Standard Premium.

The auction works like this. You set the most you are willing to pay, and the app raises your bid in small steps up to that limit. You only pay if you win. Auctions usually close 30 minutes before the train leaves its first station. Every auction also starts at a minimum opening price, which Seatfrog doesn't show you in advance.

If you would rather not bid, Upgrade Now is a fixed price. Where it is available, it appears in the app one to three days before you travel. Train Swap is the third feature. It lets you move to a different train time, and it shows the price of each alternative train before you pay.

How Seatfrog went for me

My first try at buying tickets in Seatfrog didn't go well. Every fare I searched for was much higher than I was used to paying. My best guess is that my TrainPal Card's 10% was making the difference, since Seatfrog can't apply it.

Next, I tried to upgrade. None of the trains I was actually booked on had an upgrade on offer, and only later trains did. Seatfrog says this is normal: each train company releases upgrade seats in batches, and some services never get any. On top of that, I found the bidding confusing. I wasn't sure how much to bid or what the final price would be once the fee was added.

The bidding thing I just found confusing.

Stiv, on trying Seatfrog's upgrade auctions

TrainPal vs Seatfrog: fees compared

On tickets alone, neither app charges a booking fee. The TrainPal app doesn't charge one on UK and European train tickets, apart from tickets in Spain. Seatfrog says the same about its tickets. On a straight ticket purchase, then, the price difference comes down to the fare and the discounts you can stack, and that is where TrainPal pulls ahead for me.

Upgrades are different, because Seatfrog adds a £3 booking fee per ticket to every winning bid and every Upgrade Now purchase. That fee sits on top of the price you see in the auction. For example, Which? won a London to Edinburgh upgrade with a £17 bid, so the real cost was £20 once the £3 fee went on. Which? says that was 58% less than paying Seatfrog's fixed price for the same upgrade outright. Its write-up of the test covers split tickets and Railcards too.

The fee also adds up for groups. Two people upgrading together pay £3 each, which is £6 on top of the two winning bids. In addition, children pay the same upgrade price as adults, according to Seatfrog's own auction pricing page.

Split tickets and upgrades together

Split tickets are where the two apps connect. Seatfrog lets you upgrade a split ticket, as long as your tickets cover the whole journey you are taking. That means a split ticket bought in TrainPal can still go into a Seatfrog auction.

How you add it depends on the journey. If you stay on one train with more than one ticket, you add the whole journey to Seatfrog and bid once. If you change trains, you add each train separately and bid in each auction. Each upgrade you win carries its own £3 fee, so a journey with one change can mean two fees. Seatfrog's split ticket help page has the full rule.

There is one more condition on board. You need to show both the upgrade barcode and your original standard ticket, and the upgrade only counts on the train you bid for.

Railcards in TrainPal and Seatfrog

Both apps take a Railcard on ordinary standard tickets. In TrainPal it works on split tickets too, and you can buy a digital Railcard inside the app. My Railcard discount guide covers which card suits which kind of traveller.

Seatfrog's upgrades are another matter. Railcards don't apply to upgrades, Train Swap, Secret Fare or Superfare. As a result, a Railcard holder pays the same for an upgrade as anyone else, plus the £3 fee. If you are used to a third off most fares, the upgrade price will look high next to your discounted ticket.

Loyalty and rewards

TrainPal has the bigger rewards system by far. You earn PalPoints and PalWallet cashback on every booking, and four membership tiers raise both rates as you spend more. Gold and above also adds a yearly upgrade voucher. My TrainPal membership tiers guide breaks down each tier and what the points are actually worth.

That said, I find the whole system overly complex and gamified. Status points, PalPoints, cashback and tiers all run at once, alongside games like Spin to Win. My tip is to ignore the games, because the app is very easy to use otherwise.

Seatfrog's rewards are much simpler. I struggled to find any points scheme in Seatfrog. Its refer-a-friend offer gives a new customer £5 off their first upgrade, and the person who referred them gets £5 off their next one. If you are new to Seatfrog, my Seatfrog referral link takes £5 off your first upgrade, and the £3 booking fee still applies on top.


Which one I use, and when

For now, I book every train in TrainPal. My Railcard and TrainPal Card both apply automatically, and on the fares I checked Seatfrog came out higher every time. TrainPal's split tickets also save money without me doing anything, as they did on my trip to Wales.

I haven't won a Seatfrog upgrade yet. My one attempt stalled because only later trains had upgrades on offer. Even so, the two apps can be used together. You buy the ticket in TrainPal with every discount stacked, then add it to Seatfrog if your train runs on one of the nine partner companies. If the Upgrade Now price plus the £3 fee is worth it to you, the upgrade is there to buy. If not, the cheaper ticket still stands and nothing is lost.

The same applies the other way round. Anyone already in Seatfrog for an upgrade can search the same journey in TrainPal before buying the ticket, and on my searches TrainPal came out lower. My TrainPal vs Trainline comparison puts TrainPal up against the other big ticket app.

The catches with TrainPal and Seatfrog

The complicated TrainPal rewards. Status points, PalPoints, cashback and four tiers are hard to follow, and the mini games make the app feel gamified. You only find out what any of it is worth by doing the maths yourself.

TrainPal's Delay Repay route. My last two Delay Repay claims through TrainPal still needed the train company's own form on its website, so claiming through the app didn't save me any steps.

The Seatfrog £3 fee. Every winning bid and every Upgrade Now purchase costs £3 more than the price in the auction. On a cheap upgrade, that fee is a big share of the total.

Seatfrog's unpublished starting price. Each auction opens at a minimum price that Seatfrog doesn't publish. Combined with the bidding steps, that makes it hard to know what you will pay until the auction ends.

Seatfrog's limited train coverage. Upgrades only exist on the nine partner companies, and not on every train they run. Mine weren't available, so an upgrade is never certain until it shows up in the app for your train.

TrainPal vs Seatfrog: the verdict

For buying tickets, TrainPal wins for me. It stacks my Railcard and TrainPal Card, finds split tickets on its own and charges no booking fee in the app. On my Windsor booking, the two discounts took £14.42 off two off-peak day returns, and Seatfrog had no way to match the TrainPal Card part of that.

Seatfrog is the app for First Class on a long journey, if your train runs on a partner company and has upgrades on offer. Its auctions can come in well under Seatfrog's own fixed upgrade price, as Which? found, but the £3 fee goes on top every time and Railcards don't help. In short, TrainPal vs Seatfrog doesn't need a single winner. The combination that makes sense to me is a ticket from TrainPal, then a look in Seatfrog for an upgrade when First Class is worth paying extra for.

FAQs

Is Seatfrog cheaper than TrainPal?

Not for tickets, in my experience. Every fare I searched in Seatfrog was higher than I pay in TrainPal, where my Railcard and 10% TrainPal Card both apply. Neither app charges a booking fee on tickets. Seatfrog is mainly useful for upgrades, which TrainPal doesn't auction.

Can I use a Railcard on Seatfrog?

Yes, on standard train tickets. Railcards don't apply to Seatfrog upgrades, Train Swap, Secret Fare or Superfare, so a Railcard holder pays the full upgrade price plus the £3 booking fee.

Can I upgrade a split ticket on Seatfrog?

Yes, as long as your tickets cover the whole journey. If you stay on one train with more than one ticket, add the whole journey and bid once. If you change trains, add each train separately and bid in each auction, and each upgrade you win carries its own £3 fee.

Does Seatfrog charge a booking fee?

Not on train tickets, according to Seatfrog. Upgrades are different: Seatfrog adds a £3 booking fee per ticket to every winning bid and every Upgrade Now purchase. I checked this on 8 November 2026.

Is TrainPal better than Seatfrog?

For buying tickets, TrainPal suits me better, because it stacks Railcards, the TrainPal Card and split tickets with no booking fee in the app. Seatfrog does something TrainPal doesn't, which is auction First Class upgrades. Using both, with the ticket from TrainPal and the upgrade from Seatfrog, gets the strengths of each.

More from CoolCuration

TrainPal and Seatfrog can change their fares, fees, upgrade rules and offers without notice, so check the app before you rely on any figure here. This article is not financial advice and takes no account of your circumstances.

This article contains affiliate and referral links, which are paid links. If you click one and buy or sign up, I earn a commission or referral bonus at no extra cost to you. Brands don't choose what I feature or what I say about them.


What's trending

Recent posts